Mention creatine and many people picture a tub of powder in a bodybuilder’s gym bag. That image is out of date. Creatine is now one of the most researched supplements in the world, and the people who may benefit most are not young lifters at all, but everyday adults over 40 who want to hold on to their muscle, strength and energy as they age.

It’s also cheap, simple to take and has a strong safety record in healthy adults. In this article we’ll explain what creatine actually does, what the evidence says (and doesn’t say), how to take it, and who should be careful.

What is creatine?

Creatine is a natural compound made from three amino acids. Your liver and kidneys make about a gram a day, and you get roughly another one to two grams from food if you eat meat and fish. Around 95% of it is stored in your skeletal muscles, with smaller amounts in the brain and heart.

Inside muscle, creatine is stored as phosphocreatine. Its job is to rapidly recharge ATP, the molecule your cells use for energy, during short, intense efforts: a heavy lift, a sprint for the bus, getting up off the floor, or climbing a steep Wellington street with the shopping.

Your normal diet only partly fills your creatine stores. Supplementing tops them up, typically by around 20 to 40%, with the biggest increases in people who start low, such as vegetarians, vegans and older adults.

What the research says

1. More strength and muscle from your training

This is the best-established benefit. The International Society of Sports Nutrition’s position stand, which reviewed hundreds of studies, concluded that creatine monohydrate is the most effective supplement available for increasing high-intensity exercise capacity and lean muscle mass during training.

The key words are during training. Creatine doesn’t build muscle on its own. It helps you do a little more work in each session (an extra rep or two, a bit more load), and over weeks and months that adds up.

2. Helping older adults fight muscle loss

From about our 40s, we start to lose muscle mass and strength, a process called sarcopenia. It’s one of the biggest drivers of frailty, falls and loss of independence later in life.

A 2017 meta-analysis of studies in older adults found that creatine combined with resistance training led to greater gains in lean mass and strength than resistance training alone. Some studies also suggest benefits for bone health when combined with training, though that evidence is less consistent.

The message for over-40s is simple: strength training is the main event, and creatine may help you get more from it.

3. Brain health and mental fatigue

Your brain is a heavy user of energy, and it also uses creatine. This has led to growing interest in creatine for thinking and memory.

So far, the evidence is promising but mixed. A 2018 systematic review found some improvements in short-term memory and reasoning, particularly in older adults, with less clear results in younger people. Other research suggests creatine may help most when the brain is under stress, and in vegetarians whose dietary intake is low.

One reason results vary may be the dose. Your brain only takes up a small share of the creatine you swallow, and most studies have used the standard muscle dose. Researchers such as Dr Rhonda Patrick (FoundMyFitness) have highlighted that higher intakes may be needed to meaningfully raise creatine levels in the brain.

4. Sleep deprivation

This is one of the most interesting new areas. In a 2024 study published in Scientific Reports, 15 healthy adults were kept awake overnight and given either a single large dose of creatine (0.35 grams per kilogram of body weight, roughly 20 to 30 grams for most adults) or a placebo. The creatine group performed better on memory and processing-speed tasks, and brain scans showed improved energy markers. The effect started about three hours after the dose and lasted for several hours.

It’s an exciting result, but it’s one small study. Creatine doesn’t replace sleep, and the researchers themselves cautioned that more work is needed to find the right dose and confirm it’s safe to use this way regularly.

5. Women’s health

Creatine research has historically focused on men, but that’s changing. Women naturally have lower creatine stores, and there is growing interest in its role during perimenopause and menopause, when muscle and bone loss speed up. Early results are encouraging, especially alongside resistance training, but more studies are needed.

How to take creatine

Choose creatine monohydrate. It’s the form used in almost all the research, it’s effective and it’s the cheapest. Fancier versions (creatine HCl, buffered creatine, “creatine ethyl ester”) have not been shown to work better.

Daily dose: 5 to 10 grams a day. The classic research dose for muscle is 3 to 5 grams, and that’s still enough to keep your muscles topped up. But many researchers and practitioners, including Dr Rhonda Patrick, now use 5 to 10 grams a day, with the higher end aimed at brain benefits as well as muscle. A level teaspoon of powder is about 5 grams. Take it every day, including rest days. Timing doesn’t matter much, so pick whatever time you’ll remember. Many people mix it into their morning coffee, a smoothie or a post-workout shake.

After a bad night’s sleep: a one-off 15 to 30 grams. Based on the sleep-deprivation research above, some people take a single larger dose (roughly 0.35 grams per kilogram of body weight) on a day after poor sleep. Treat this as occasional, not daily. Split it across the morning with food and plenty of water to avoid stomach upset, and skip it if you have any kidney concerns. The evidence here is early, so think of it as an option to discuss with your GP rather than a proven protocol.

Loading is optional. Some people take about 20 grams a day (split into four doses) for five to seven days to fill their muscles faster, then drop to 3 to 5 grams. Without loading, your stores reach the same level after around three to four weeks. Skipping the loading phase is gentler on the stomach.

Be patient. You won’t feel creatine working like caffeine. Its benefits build quietly over weeks, as part of consistent training.

Choose a tested product. Supplements aren’t tightly regulated. Look for products that are third-party tested (for example, carrying the Informed Sport or Informed Choice mark), especially if you compete in drug-tested sport.

Common creatine myths

“Creatine is a steroid.” It isn’t. It’s a compound your body makes every day and that you eat in meat and fish.

“It damages your kidneys.” In healthy people, long-term studies at normal doses have not shown kidney harm. However, creatine can raise creatinine on a blood test, a marker doctors use to check kidney function. This doesn’t mean your kidneys are damaged, but tell your GP you’re taking creatine so they can interpret the results correctly.

“It causes hair loss.” This concern comes from a single 2009 study in rugby players that found a rise in a hormone linked to hair loss (DHT). That study didn’t measure hair loss, and the result hasn’t been repeated. Current evidence doesn’t show that creatine causes hair loss, but if you’re worried, talk to your doctor.

“It makes you bloated.” Creatine draws water into your muscles, so you may gain around 1 to 2 kilograms in the first few weeks. This is water inside the muscle, not fat. Stomach upset is uncommon at normal daily doses and is more likely with larger single doses, so split bigger amounts through the day.

Who should be careful

Creatine is considered safe for most healthy adults, but check with your GP first if you:

  • Have kidney disease, or a condition or medication that affects your kidneys
  • Have diabetes or liver disease
  • Are pregnant or breastfeeding
  • Are under 18

Practical tips

  1. Start with your training. Creatine works best alongside two or more strength sessions a week.
  2. Keep it simple. Plain creatine monohydrate, 5 to 10 grams a day, every day.
  3. Make it a habit. Keep it next to the kettle or coffee machine so you don’t forget.
  4. Drink enough water. Normal hydration is fine. There’s no need to force down extra litres.
  5. Give it time. Judge it over two to three months of consistent training, not a week or two.
  6. Get your protein right too. Creatine is not a substitute for enough protein, which is still the foundation of building and keeping muscle.

Conclusion

Creatine has moved well beyond the bodybuilding world. For adults over 40, it’s one of the few supplements with strong evidence behind it, and it’s an easy, affordable way to get more out of strength training and help protect your muscle as you age. The research on brain health and women’s health is exciting too, though still developing.

As with any supplement, it works best alongside the basics: regular strength training, enough protein, good sleep and staying active.

Want a strength programme that helps you build and keep muscle at any age? Our trainers can put together a plan that suits your goals, whether you train at home, in the park or at our Johnsonville studio. Book a free consultation with Advantage Fitness, call us on 022 0246 145, or email enquire@advantagefitness.co.nz.

This article is general information only and is not medical advice. Check with your GP before starting any supplement if you have a medical condition or take medication.


References